First I want to say that I love the gloves, and I think the idea of them is wonderful. That being said no matter how great they are they do have a glaringly obvious design flaw. The glove tips that can be bent back to reveal your finger skin are not large enough. They barely cover your fingers when down, and because they are so small the screen friendly material on the tips gets twisted and bent out of place making it a bit difficult to manipulate the screen. If the tips of the gloves were only made with a little more length in the fabric they could be perfect and worthy of that fifth star because they are in fact warm and durable gloves. The screen touch material works well when it's in the proper position, and the gloves fit well apart from the finger tips being a tad small. Great idea and product! I just think it can be tweaked that tiny little bit to make them perfect.